Expropriation Law Centre


You are here: Home > Photos


Cohen Highley LLP


Arbutus Corridor railway line
Vancouver, British Columbia
This is a collection of photos showing the Arbutus Corridor railway line in Vancouver. The railway is owned by the Canadian Pacific Railway and it has been the subject of extended litigation between the CPR and the City of Vancouver. The litigation involved an allegation by the CPR that the City had constructively expropriated the CPR's property by enacting a land use bylaw that restricted lawful uses for the property. The case was finally decided by the Supreme Court of Canada in February 2006. Copies of the court decisions are available to subscribers on the Online Subscription Service. The SCC decision is cited as: [2006] EXLAW 301.

March 2006

While the track and other railway equipment was still in place at the time these photos were taken in March 2006 the railway had not been in active use for about six years.

Looking south along the rail line from the 16th Avenue crossing. Here the rail line is sandwiched between two parallel streets, Arbutus Street on the right and East Boulevard on the left. Arbutus is a major north-south connector street with four driving lanes at this point. East Boulevard provides access to five consecutive city blocks where single family residential properties have been developed on the east side. DSC02122.JPG
Looking north from the 17th Avenue pedestrian crossing. Arbutus Street is on the left and East Boulevard is on the right. Residential development is apparent to the right of East Boulevard. DSC02129.JPG
Looking northwest from the 17th Avenue pedestrian crossing. A commercial development at the NW corner of Arbutus Street and 16th Avenue is visible at the left side of the photo. DSC02131.JPG
Looking southeast along the tracks from the West King Edward Avenue crossing. The B.C. Hydro Sperling Substation is visible to the right of the tracks. DSC02133.JPG
Looking northwest along the tracks near the B.C. Hydro Sperling Substation. The large building on the left side of the tracks is the electric substation. Maple Crescent is parallel to the rail corridor behind the large hedge on the right. The photo also shows several overhead electric transmission lines located within the railway right of way. DSC02137.JPG

August 2014

During the eight year period following the 2006 court decision little if any maintenance work was performed on the Arbutus rail line and no rail operations took place. However, in 2014 the CPR gave notice of its intention to clear the right of way and restore the track to operating condition. At that time the railway's website identified a significant number of encroachments on the right of way placed there by other parties. Some news reports suggested this decision was primarily intended by the CPR to enhance its bargaining position with the City in relation to a possible sale of the land to the City or perhaps a relaxation of the land use restrictions. Clearing operations commenced in August 2014.

Looking north from the 17th Avenue pedestrian crossing. This photo is taken from the same location as one of the March 2006 photos above. DSC07657B.JPG
Looking northwest along the tracks near the B.C. Hydro Sperling Substation. This photo is taken from the same location as one of the March 2006 photos above. DSC07655B.JPG
Close up view of the track near the West 64th Avenue pedestrian crossing. This photo reveals deterioration in the ties and track. The spray painted white spots appear to identify parts that require repair or replacement. DSC07641B.JPG
Garden located on the railway right of way near West 68th Avenue. DSC00130B.JPG
Public notice stapled to a trellis located in a garden on the right of way near West 68th Avenue. DSC00126B.JPG
Public notice taped to a street sign adjacent to the East Boulevard Community Garden. DSC00125B.JPG
Railway ballast maintenance equipment is shown parked on the track a short distance north of the SW Marine Drive crossing. This equipment was used during clearing operations in August 2014. DSC00129B.JPG
Looking south from the SW Marine Drive crossing where clearing operations took place on August 15, 2014. DSC00135B.JPG
Looking north towards the SW Marine Drive crossing on August 15, 2014. The photo was taken in the early evening when numerous visitors were in attendance inspecting the recent changes. DSC00138B.JPG
Looking east near the southern limit of the Arbutus section of the railway. The Hudson Street crossing is visible and the junction with the active rail line that continues to New Westminster lies a short distance beyond. The north approach ramps for the Arthur Laing bridge are overhead. DSC07635B.JPG
Join the Mailing List
Enter your name and email address below:


Online Subscription
Online Subscription Service sign-up
Online Subscription Service log-in