Advertisement
|
|
[Back] |
DECISION DIGEST |
|
Record no. 483 |
|
Case name: |
Sutherland v. Canada (Attorney General) |
|
|
Jurisdiction: |
Canada - British Columbia |
|
|
|
|
|
Parties: |
Name |
|
Appearing as |
|
Anglet, Hildegard |
|
Claimant |
|
Aziz, Alnoor |
|
Claimant |
|
Aziz, Amina |
|
Claimant |
|
Bains, Kashmir |
|
Claimant |
|
Bains, Narinder Kaur |
|
Claimant |
|
Barnes, H. Elaine |
|
Claimant |
|
Bayazit, Anita |
|
Claimant |
|
Bhoparai, Makhan |
|
Claimant |
|
Bhoparai, Shabinder |
|
Claimant |
|
Bjornson, Bjorn |
|
Claimant |
|
Bjornson, Elizabeth |
|
Claimant |
|
Boal, Christl |
|
Claimant |
|
Boal, Robert |
|
Claimant |
|
Bremer, Darrell |
|
Claimant |
|
Bremer, Gail |
|
Claimant |
|
Brownell, Christine |
|
Claimant |
|
Chan, Tak Wah |
|
Claimant |
|
Chang, Su-Haw |
|
Claimant |
|
Charles, Susan |
|
Claimant |
|
Charles, Trevor |
|
Claimant |
|
Cheng, Norman |
|
Claimant |
|
Choquer, Dorothy |
|
Claimant |
|
Chui, Ngai-Sim |
|
Claimant |
|
D'Aguiar, Tessa |
|
Claimant |
|
DeGiorgio, Frank |
|
Claimant |
|
Degiorgio, Maria |
|
Claimant |
|
Doyle, Paul |
|
Claimant |
|
Eklof, Marion |
|
Claimant |
|
Eklof, Wayne |
|
Claimant |
|
Esmail, Abdul Jamal |
|
Claimant |
|
Esmail, Shirin Jamal |
|
Claimant |
|
Ginter, Keith |
|
Claimant |
|
Ginter, Sharon |
|
Claimant |
|
Gosal, Balvinder |
|
Claimant |
|
Grewal, Baljit |
|
Claimant |
|
Grewal, Paul |
|
Claimant |
|
Grewal, Yaseen |
|
Claimant |
|
Greyval, Ross |
|
Claimant |
|
Harder, Laura |
|
Claimant |
|
Harder, Walter |
|
Claimant |
|
Harris, Audrey |
|
Claimant |
|
Harris, Kevin |
|
Claimant |
|
Harris, Todd |
|
Claimant |
|
Hastings, Howard |
|
Claimant |
|
Hastings, Y. Marie |
|
Claimant |
|
Herman, Anita |
|
Claimant |
|
Herman, Ronald |
|
Claimant |
|
Hourie, Robert |
|
Claimant |
|
Hourie, Stephane |
|
Claimant |
|
Ip, Ellen |
|
Claimant |
|
Ip, Jim |
|
Claimant |
|
Jamal, Axix |
|
Claimant |
|
Jamal, Farzana |
|
Claimant |
|
Jerominski, Edith |
|
Claimant |
|
Johnson, Linda |
|
Claimant |
|
Jones, Andrea |
|
Claimant |
|
Jones, Robin |
|
Claimant |
|
Kaethler, Helen |
|
Claimant |
|
Kanda, Gurjant |
|
Claimant |
|
Kanda, Sarita |
|
Claimant |
|
Kempe, Eduard |
|
Claimant |
|
Kempe, Thea |
|
Claimant |
|
Korac, Peter |
|
Claimant |
|
Laferriere, Delia |
|
Claimant |
|
Laferriere, Denis |
|
Claimant |
|
Laing, John |
|
Claimant |
|
Laing, Laurie |
|
Claimant |
|
Leech, Anne |
|
Claimant |
|
Leech, Victor |
|
Claimant |
|
Leong, Betty |
|
Claimant |
|
Leong, Michael |
|
Claimant |
|
Li, Christine |
|
Claimant |
|
Li, James |
|
Claimant |
|
Lilly, Amrik |
|
Claimant |
|
Liu, Tommy |
|
Claimant |
|
Livingstone, Brett |
|
Claimant |
|
Livingstone, Glen |
|
Claimant |
|
Livingstone, Laura |
|
Claimant |
|
Livingstone, Lisa |
|
Claimant |
|
Martin, David |
|
Claimant |
|
Martin, Mick |
|
Claimant |
|
Martin, Mortimer |
|
Claimant |
|
Martin, Theodora |
|
Claimant |
|
McFadyen, Clara |
|
Claimant |
|
McFadyen, Stanley |
|
Claimant |
|
McLeod, Neil |
|
Claimant |
|
Mulholland, David |
|
Claimant |
|
Musgrave, Norman |
|
Claimant |
|
Musgrave, Pauline |
|
Claimant |
|
Nakano, Louise |
|
Claimant |
|
Nakano, Shinichi |
|
Claimant |
|
Ng, Lucy |
|
Claimant |
|
Ngai, Sammy |
|
Claimant |
|
Ngui-Yen, John |
|
Claimant |
|
Ngui-Yen, Joycelyn |
|
Claimant |
|
Nijjar, Satvir |
|
Claimant |
|
Nijjar, Sukhvir |
|
Claimant |
|
Novak, Zeljka |
|
Claimant |
|
Okak, Hazoori |
|
Claimant |
|
Olak, Kamaljit |
|
Claimant |
|
Olak, Major |
|
Claimant |
|
Olak, Mohan |
|
Claimant |
|
Olak, Pommy |
|
Claimant |
|
Orth, Carole Ann |
|
Claimant |
|
Orth, Robert |
|
Claimant |
|
Padvaiskas, Linda |
|
Claimant |
|
Padvaiskas, Richard |
|
Claimant |
|
Page, Helen |
|
Claimant |
|
Pahl, Lehmber |
|
Claimant |
|
Pahl, Narinder |
|
Claimant |
|
Pearce, Gail |
|
Claimant |
|
Pearce, Richard C. |
|
Claimant |
|
Puri, Robyn |
|
Claimant |
|
Quinlan, Edwin |
|
Claimant |
|
Rachel, Martin |
|
Claimant |
|
Rachel, Shellie |
|
Claimant |
|
Reyes, Armando |
|
Claimant |
|
Reyes, Susana |
|
Claimant |
|
Sahota, Susan |
|
Claimant |
|
Sarghie, Hans |
|
Claimant |
|
Schunter, Gerhard |
|
Claimant |
|
Schunter, Gloria |
|
Claimant |
|
Seagrave, Suzanne |
|
Claimant |
|
Seagrave, Thomas |
|
Claimant |
|
Sethi, Mehnga |
|
Claimant |
|
Sethi, Sukdev |
|
Claimant |
|
Sharma, Hemendra |
|
Claimant |
|
Sharma, Sitla |
|
Claimant |
|
Singh, Jit |
|
Claimant |
|
Singh, Mangal |
|
Claimant |
|
Soltice, Michael |
|
Claimant |
|
Sutherland, Sherryl Sara Stewart |
|
Claimant |
|
Sutherland, Wilfred Gary |
|
Claimant |
|
Thorsen, Ingrid |
|
Claimant |
|
Thorsen, John |
|
Claimant |
|
Tong, Kitty |
|
Claimant |
|
Tonks, Patricia S. |
|
Claimant |
|
Twiss, Tangerine |
|
Claimant |
|
Verma, Arun |
|
Claimant |
|
Verma, Bimal |
|
Claimant |
|
Verma, Des |
|
Claimant |
|
Walsh, Barry |
|
Claimant |
|
Wells, Sylvia |
|
Claimant |
|
Wickham, Casey |
|
Claimant |
|
Wickham, Maryanne |
|
Claimant |
|
Wolff, Martha |
|
Claimant |
|
Wolff, Peter |
|
Claimant |
|
Wood, Telma |
|
Claimant |
|
Yeung, Habiba |
|
Claimant |
|
Canada (Attorney General) |
|
Authority |
|
Vancouver International Airport Authority |
|
Authority |
|
Canadian Airports Council |
|
Other |
|
Before: |
Decision maker |
Designation |
|
Finch, Lance S.G. |
C.J.B.C. |
|
Hall, John Edward |
J.A. |
|
Prowse, Jo-Ann E. |
J.A. |
|
Lawyers: |
Name |
|
Appearing for |
|
Roberts, Darrell W. |
|
Claimant |
|
Shewfelt, John R. |
|
Claimant |
|
Borrell, Andrew D. |
|
Authority |
|
Carruthers, George C. |
|
Authority |
|
Rosenfeld, Glenn |
|
Authority |
|
Seckel, Allan P. |
|
Authority |
|
Jamal, Mahmud |
|
Other |
|
Morgan, Brian G. |
|
Other |
|
|
|
|
|
Decision: |
Appeal by the Authority from a damage award for nuisance caused by aircraft using the Vancouver International Airport. Cross-appeal by the Claimants on several issues relating to the assessment of damages. The Authority argued that there was no nuisance or alternatively, that if there was a nuisance, the defence of statutory authority applied. On the appeal, the court found that there was a nuisance but allowed the appeal on the ground that the defence of statutory authority applied in these circumstances. Appeal allowed and award of damages set aside. |
|
|
|
|
|
Neutral citation: |
2002 BCCA 416 |
|
ExLaw citation: |
[2002] EXLAW 316 |
|
Parallel citations: |
(2002) 114 A.C.W.S. (3d) 982 |
|
(2002) 170 B.C.A.C. 233 |
|
[2002] B.C.J. No. 1479 |
|
(2002) 4 B.C.L.R. (4th) 205 |
|
(2002) 12 C.C.L.T. (3d) 106 |
|
(2002) 46 C.E.L.R. (N.S.) 163 |
|
(2002) 215 D.L.R. (4th) 1 |
|
(2002) 279 W.A.C. 233 |
|
[2002] 10 W.W.R. 1 |
|
|
Digests contain original content produced by ExLaw and copyright in
this content is held by Dicta Legal Services Ltd. (dba Expropriation Law Centre).
Reasons for decision are the text of original decisions released by the court
or tribunal and edited for accuracy where required. No copyright is claimed
for these materials.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Online Subscription Service
|
|
|
|
Advertisement
|